Rent the Runway Review

This past weekend I wore a $500 Tibi dress that only cost me $40. I kinda wish I had a crazy story in which I knocked out an innocent bystander who got in my way at a sample sale, but in truth it was really easy and non-violent. I rented it!

Rent The Runway is a dress and accessory rental website based in New York, the same concept as Bag Borrow or Steal. The selection does not disappoint and has grown immensely since the website launched two years ago. Big labels like DVF, Vera Wang, Catherine Malandrino, Missoni and Moschino are mixed with fun, young labels like Rachel Roy, Doo.ri, Alice + Olivia, Tibi, Milly, See by Choé and Christian Siriano.

The price for  rent is about 10% of the retail value of the dress, with the majority priced $50-$150.

Almost a year ago, I bought one of those Groupon-like deals for RTR: $40 for $100 worth of rentals. I had a holiday party coming up with my college girlfriends and decided to scour the website to find something. Normally I might save renting for a bigger occasion like a wedding, but I took my sweet time cashing in and my deal was about to expire.

I’m really into lace right now and wanted something with sleeves, so after debating a few styles I went with this navy Tibi dress:

Babbet Lace Shift Dress by Tibi

Isn’t she lovely? When my box arrived two days before my party, I found this inside:

My dress came inside a garment bag (That you get to keep! This was news to me and a little more exciting to me than it probably should have been) as well as a pre-paid return envelope, fashion tape (not needed, but appreciated) and a note with the date I needed to return my dress.

The rental period is 4 days (or you can pay more for 8 days) and its recommend you have your dress delivered a day or two prior to your event. To return, all you do is put the dress in the padded envelope and stick in in a regular ‘ole blue USPS mailbox. So simple! If I had to take the package to a physical post office or UPS location, this would have been a total pain and a deal-breaker.

When I opened up my garment bag, I was very happy with the quality of the dress. It looked brand new with no sign of being worn before. The dress had obviously been dry cleaned because it smelled nice. Yeah, I smelled my dress.

The dress was just a tad big on me (better than too small!), and nothing a belt couldn’t fix. Here’s how I wore it:

Messy bun, red skinny belt, black tights and grey ankle booties.

Ordering was easy, but renting for the first time can be a little scary. Here are a few tips:

1. Read the “size and fit” details (very helpful) and the reviews written by other renters (extremely helpful). They send you two sizes and this will help you determine if you should size up or down. Usually up, since many designer labels run small.

2. Google your dress. You might find more pictures and more reviews that could be helpful and give more insight into the fit of the dress. I wish RTR would invest in video the way ASOS does, which would really be above and beyond.

3. Don’t make this stressful; have a backup. If you want, you can add a second dress to your order for just $25. The bigger tip here is that this would be a great deal for a week when you have back-to-back events or are renting with a friend.

5. Place your order as far in advance as you can for the best selection, but know you have the option for last-minute rentals. I placed mine the week before my party and the smaller of the two sizes I wanted was out of stock. This was disappointing but landed up not being a big deal to me. If the dress landed up not working for any reason, I could return it and receive my money back.

Renting dresses, when men have been renting tuxes for, I don’t know, always, is one of those “why didn’t I think of that?” ideas. Here’s the back story: RTR was founded by two women who met in Harvard business school. They went from not knowing a soul in the fashion industry to creating relationships with big-name designers and have secured millions (and millions) from investors. Keeping their stock fresh and on-trend has to be their biggest challenge–but from what I’ve read, the company started turning a profit a year after launching. If the growth of their website is any indication of how well they’re doing, I would say very.

I loved this dress and was a little sad to return it, but it’s all about progression. I’m on to the next one, on to the next. Would you rent, or have you rented before?


12 thoughts on “Rent the Runway Review

  1. I’ve never used Rent the Runway, but this description makes it seem so doable. I always thought of it as too intimidating. But now, it sounds like it’s really user friendly. Thanks for the step-by-step of how it all works. It’s SO helpful for the less daring fashionistas among us.

    And it goes without saying, but you look SO CUTE in your dress! Love the hair. And I would never have thought to add a red belt.
    Style Alter is the best.

  2. After reading this post i would FOR SURE try renting! the fact you get 2 sizes is KEY!!! Also the fact it’s free to return and also they’ll refund your money if the dress doesn’t end up working. The success of this company is all about customer service. Making the renter feel safe and secure that they can take a chance on something without much risk. I am going to totally check this out now!!! Thanks Lynn! ps love how the dress looked on you!

    • Lauren,

      I saw a few on the site that I can wear for your wedding! I might start renting for my brother’s wedding just to make sure that it goes smoothly. Thanks Lynn!!

  3. I have not rented before but I am super excited to try. I heard about Rent the Runway awhile back but was a little hesitant to try since I didn’t know of anyone who actually used it. Now that I have a trustworthy source telling me that it was an awesome experience, I will DEFINITELY try and use it for future events. I’ll keep you updated as to how that goes. 🙂 and yes, I agree with everyone else, I thought that dress looked GREAT on you.

  4. My friend used Rent the Runway last year and scored an awesome dress to wear to a wedding. It fit great and looked fierce. After seeing this Tibi number, I am sold. I hear they rent bridesmaid dresses now too!

  5. Very helpful post! You looked fab in this!!!

    My biggest hurdle to using RTR is that, with pricing between $50-$150, I always convince myself that I will be able to find a dress to actually buy and own that won’t be all that much more expensive. However, I’m not a great bargain shopper, and my Bergdorfs tastes are starting to outgrow my Macys budget. Need to try this soon!!

  6. RTR is great, especially for weddings! In one shipment I rented a dress for my rehearsal dinner, a bracelet that I wore with my wedding dress, and a pair of earrings and a bracelet that my mom wore to the wedding. Everything looked fab and arrived in perfect condition. Remember to check out the jewelry rental – a great way to change up a dress for $10-$50 (ish). They also email coupon codes all the time, so get on their email list if you think you will rent soon.

  7. I rented from this place twice and I did not have the luck you did. Both times the dresses were dirty, old and nasty and nasty and both times I call last minute telling me, “the dresses you order are not available”. My advice: have a back-up dress if you ever plan on renting from them.

  8. Almost two weeks ago I rented a gown from RTR for the Inaugural Ball. Yesterday, Jocelyn contacted me saying that my dress was not available anymore. It made me really disappointed! Megan then told me that I could choose any other dress and they would send me it on time. Of course, the options they had left where not good. So they send me two dresses that I just got today, and both dresses did not fit me well. I called RTR many times, and I also sent them and e-mail. I never received any call or message back. That how this website works. They really do not care about you! The Ball is on Monday, and tomorrow I am going to have to run to the stores to try to find a dress, or I am going to miss the ball. And no one from the RTR cares.

  9. Pingback: mintpeony

Your Turn. Got a Comment?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s